What I have seen first hand: The privacy revolution in paid
I have been working in Paid Marketing for the past 12 years, and during this period paid marketing has undergone a fundamental shift. The transformation has been largely driven by the privacy revolution, spurred by legislation like GDPR and growing user concerns (leading to ad blockers), as well as significant changes made by ad platforms themselves. These platforms, motivated by both regulatory pressures and strategic business interests (!), have increasingly embraced black-box models and walled gardens.
Before the privacy revolution, the primary competitive advantage in paid marketing lay in platform optimization. Agencies and in-house teams that mastered bidding strategies, automation, and other technical aspects were the ones that succeeded. This is something I have seen first hand.
However, as ad platforms left less and less room for customizations and innovative approaches, two areas gained prominence: Creative and Data & Analytics. Today, advertisers who leverage data effectively and provide the right signals to ad platforms are more likely to achieve success.
Similarly, those who implement sophisticated creative strategies, advanced asset management, and robust performance measurement processes will stand out.
You might wonder; how does this leads us to Organic?
AI has already revolutionized paid!
Let's first just align on the fact that Ad platforms have been leveraging AI for years. One prime example of AI's influence is bidding. Traditional manual bidding strategies have been largely replaced by AI-powered automated bidding systems.
This shift towards AI-driven bidding has, in many ways, reduced the degree of control that agencies and in-house teams have over campaign performance. While AI offers significant advantages in terms of efficiency and precision, it also diminishes the ability to fine-tune strategies through manual intervention.
It's very important to have this in mind, that, in this new landscape, the key to success lies in providing high-quality data to the AI algorithms. However, the ultimate power still resides with the ad platforms themselves, as they control the underlying algorithms and data infrastructure.
AI is both driver and the solution for Organic going forward
While this may not be groundbreaking news to you, it's important to have this clarified before exploring the parallels between paid and organic marketing. Just as the fundamental shifts in paid marketing began eight years ago, organic marketing is now facing a similarly significant transformation.
Generative AI is both the catalyst and the potential solution (if done right!). Large Language Models (LLMs) pose a significant threat to Google, leading to the rapid rollout of AI Overviews. Whether users interact with Google Search, Bing, Perplexity, or ChatGPT, they'll increasingly ask direct questions, moving away from keyword-based searches. Instead of limiting themselves to what they think Google understands, they will ask the questions they really want an answer on.
This is a major shift in search behavior. Actually, even the concept of search queries is and will be redundant within a short period of time. Search queries or not, the core change is that users expect a much more precise and customized answer to their questions. This leads to completely different requirements on the content needed. The content needs to be both of higher quality, more specific, and contextually relevant content.
So, if this was the driver of the change, you might understand how AI also could be the solution to the problem (or opportunity!)?
How brands are doing Content and SEO today
But first, let's examine four common scenarios within content and SEO, faced by brands. I think you will recognize at least a couple of the outlined approaches?
High-quality but low-discoverability content: Brands that produces engaging, high-quality content (to a pretty high cost), but struggle to make it discoverable through search engines - falls into this category.
Low-quality but high-ranking content: Brands that prioritize search engine optimization over content quality, resulting in generic, soulless content. Up until now however Google has premiered this type of content, meaning brands continue to produce it. Does it really help the end user and build a great experience of the brand? Most likely not.
High-quality but with limited scalability: Brands that successfully combine quality and SEO but face challenges scaling their content production across multiple markets or long-tail keywords, falls into this category.
The final category of brands popped up this past year: Recycled AI-generated content. Early adopters of AI-generated content often struggle with quality control and ensuring alignment with brand voice and tone.
How to leverage AI for content success?
AI could solve the scalability problem, both from a content research perspective (adaptation to each market) but also, of course, from a production/translation perspective.
However, to effectively use AI, brands must focus on AI amplification, rather than AI recycling . But what does AI amplification really mean?
In short: it involves feeding models with high-quality data, providing clear instructions, and incorporating human creativity to refine and elevate AI-generated content.
Why Organic and Paid actually will be very similar
So, back to the questions on what Organic actually can learn from Paid. Disciplines of SEO that were previously the driving force (backlinks, technical SEO) are now commodities (or not relevant), just like optimization within the ad platforms themselves for paid marketing. The real game-changer for SEO is content.
To succeed with content, brands must excel at both the creative/strategic aspect (enhancing human creativity) and the technical/automation aspect (prompt engineering, context provision, scaled production, etc.). This is very similar to the competencies that both paid marketing agencies and in-house teams have been desperately trying to develop, retain, and hire for the last few years.
Within paid marketing, to succeed in the challenging task of feeding ad platforms (and end-users) with the right data and creative assets, the creative/strategic aspects of both the creative and data & analytics sides must be emphasized. Give examples. On the other hand, the ability to execute innovative strategies and insights is equally important. Building, applying, and maintaining the right automation, technical, and data modeling solutions is key.
To sum up, in paid marketing, the fundamentals (platform optimization and structure) must be in place. The "secret sauce" is creativity/strategic ability (across creative and data & analytics) and deep hands-on competence in tech, automation, and data & analytics.
In organic/SEO, the fundamentals (site performance, tech SEO) must also be in place. However, the secret sauce/competitive edge is content, fueled by the same skills as in paid marketing: creativity, strategic thinking (to enhance human creativity with AI), and deep hands-on competence in tech, automation, and data & analytics to feed LLMs with the right data and instruct the models (prompt engineering) at scale.
The optimal organization for Content marketing and SEO
Lessons learned from paid marketing
-
Given the required skill set, hybrid profiles combining strategic/creative ability with deep technical skills are becoming increasingly important. While true hybrid roles are primarily found in in-house teams, it's worth noting that these roles are challenging to fill and execute.
-
Agencies, on the other hand, have the luxury to develop and hire a bit more of specialist, in each of the domains (creative/strategic vs. technical). What is non-negotiable however, for agencies in the forefront, is that no one could “just” be a strategist (with little/no anchoring in the technical side of things) and vice versa.
-
Rather than organizing teams by channel, a more effective approach is to focus on outcomes and skill sets, serving multiple channels as needed.
Outdated Approaches to Content Marketing and SEO
Siloing SEO: Treating SEO as a purely technical function, isolated from content strategy.
Content teams disregarding AI and discoverability: Failing to leverage AI tools and prioritize content discoverability.
The future way of working with Content marketing and SEO
1. Develop and hire hybrid profiles, inspired by paid. It could be a creative/strategical person who has a drive to utilize the new technology available (AI Content Software or out-of-the box LLM:s). But it could also be a more technical trained person who could get integrated into the Content team.
- It will not be possible to own “Content” without also owning the discoverable/performance aspect (beside the brand aspect). With other words, SEO will not be owned by the web/tech-team, but by the Content team.
3. Siloes will need to be broken between Content, SEO, PR and Social. Stay tuned for exploring more about breaking silos between Content, SEO, PR and Social!
#Organization
